Jurisdiction Intelligence Report

Personal Injury Case Values in New York (2026)

Data-driven verdict and settlement analysis for Personal Injury cases in New York. Median outcome: $10.7M across 14 tracked cases.

Verdicts Tracked
14
Median Outcome
$10.7M
Mean Outcome
$26.3M
Range
$1.2M–$160.0M

Verdict Distribution

RangeCasesPercent
$1M–$5M429%
$5M+1071%

Key Valuation Factors

Severity and permanency of plaintiff's injuriesDefendant's institutional status and perceived deep pocketsDegree of comparative fault allocated to each partyAvailability and strength of expert medical and economic testimonyVulnerability of plaintiff (age, occupation, prior health status)

Key Trends & Insights

Personal Injury verdicts and settlements in New York reflect a strongly plaintiff-favorable environment, with a median outcome of $10.7M and a mean of $26.3M across tracked cases, indicating that high-value outlier verdicts — such as the $160M award in Jane Doe v. NYC Board of Ed. — are significantly skewing average outcomes upward. Institutional defendants, including government entities like NYC Transit Authority and the NYC Board of Education, appear frequently and are facing substantial jury awards, suggesting that cases involving systemic negligence or vulnerable plaintiffs draw particularly aggressive valuations. New York's pure comparative negligence standard and absence of a non-economic damages cap continue to empower juries to return unconstrained verdicts, reinforcing the state's reputation as one of the most plaintiff-favorable jurisdictions in the country.

Notable Cases

Plaintiff v. Eli Lilly Sales Representative $13.5M
2025 · Block O'Toole & Murphy

A 24-year-old woman walking on St. Johnland Road was struck by a company-owned vehicle driven by an Eli Lilly pharmaceutical sales rep traveling near 50 mph. She sustained catastrophic injuries including left frontal lobe TBI, preventing her from testifying. Case settled for a record $13.5M in Suffo

View Source →
Jane Doe v. NYC Board of Ed., et al. $160.0M
2024 · TopVerdict.com

An institutional-liability sexual abuse/assault case listed by TopVerdict among the top U.S. personal injury verdicts of 2024. The entry includes practice-area tags and counsel but not the specific court.

View Source →
Gomez-Martinez v. NYC Transit Authority, et al $12.2M
2024 · TopVerdict.com

TopVerdict lists this as a 2024 New York jury verdict arising from a bus vs bicycle crash with fracture and spinal injuries noted in the case-type tags.

View Source →
Ferreira v. Volmar Constr. Inc., et al. $6.1M
2024 · TopVerdict.com

TopVerdict lists this as a 2024 New York jury verdict arising from a rear-end collision with spinal and neurological injuries noted in the case-type tags.

View Source →
Miranda v. Curry, et al. $9.3M
2024 · TopVerdict.com

TopVerdict lists this as a 2024 New York jury verdict involving a truck crash, spinal injury, and permanent disability, with government negligence alleged per case-type tags.

View Source →

Get Your Case Evaluated

Use Harlan's AI-powered engine to analyze your Personal Injury case in New York against this verdict data.

Evaluate My Case →